February 26, 2025
Written by: Quincy Bentley & Hannah Field | Sports Editor & Editor-in-Chief
Western is at the center of a high-profile lawsuit, as nine former women’s basketball players have filed a lawsuit seeking $28 million in damages. The plaintiffs have filed claims not only against the university but also individually against the university’s president, athletic director, dean of students, head coach Jessica Peatross and assistant coach Demetrius “DJ” Marlow. The claim, filed in January 2025, alleges that all defendants took actions to retaliate against plaintiffs.
The university previously conducted an internal investigation against the coaching staff in 2024, canceling their season 23 games in. The investigation resulted in no substantiated claims against the coaches, leading the university to bring back both Peatross and Marlow and, consequently, the former players to seek legal consequences after the alleged abuse. According to the lawsuit, Peatross and Marlow engaged in a pattern of abusive behavior such as excessive conditioning, medical negligence and mental health interference.
In the case of excessive conditioning, players claim they were subjected to grueling training sessions that led to dehydration, exhaustion and injuries. Cali McClave, the team’s leading scorer and captain last season, stated, “I played at Western for five years, and as an athlete, you’re built to be able to do conditioning; to be able to do a lot. A lot of it is mental toughness, but they used it in the way of fear and a way of (saying), ‘I’m holding this over your head. I have all the power here.’ Pretty much everyone was in the training room due to these coaches and that excessive running.”
Key factors in the medical negligence claim include statements from Ana McClave, the sister of Cali McClave, who is also one of the nine players involved in the lawsuit. As a junior guard for Western last year, Ana alleged she was pressured to participate in practices despite not being medically cleared after knee surgery. Additionally, during a bout of bronchitis, even with a doctor’s note to excuse her, she claimed she was forced to play.
Former forward Jodi Noyes also had a lot to say about the mental health interferences she experienced while playing under Peatross. Noyes reported that coaches urged her to discontinue prescribed antidepressant medication. She was allegedly mocked with the nickname “Eeyore” and told that taking medication before games made her weak. “(Peatross) would question me before games and stuff being like, ‘Did you take it today?’ One time I missed a shot in the middle of a game and just wasn’t playing good, and (Marlow) ripped me out. He was like, ‘Jodi, did you take your pills today?'” Noyes stated.
Players who voiced concerns claim they faced severe consequences, including increased conditioning, less playing time and, in some cases, expulsion from the team. The situation escalated further Feb. 12, 2024, when Peatross filed a police report accusing freshman guard Hanne Hopkins of assault. Surveillance footage disproved the claim, but the lawsuit alleges this was a “false police report” as well as an attempt to intimidate players into silence. The plaintiffs argue that Western failed to take adequate action despite multiple complaints.
When the coaches were reinstated in April 2024, six of the eight players who had filed complaints and still had remaining eligibility were dismissed from the team by Peatross and Marlow.
In 2024, “The Western Howl” covered this incident, gathering information from multiple sources to provide a detailed account of the situation. Reflecting on Peatross’ past, the original article included the following quote: “An anonymous source stated that ‘The head coach lied on her resume that she played division one basketball when she didn’t.’ Further investigation shows that the introductions for Coach Peatross into both Salem University and Western Oregon University included that ‘Peatross received a Division-1 scholarship to play golf, basketball and track at Chicago State University’ — however, there are no digital records of Peatross ever competing or being on the roster of the Chicago State women’s basketball roster between 2010-2014, when she attended the university; there are records of Peatross competing at Chicago State in track and field and golf.”
After reaching out to both sides of the legal dispute, “The Western Howl” was able to get a statement from attorney Jason Kafoury, who is representing the nine former players. As for the university, “The Western Howl” was informed, “The university cannot comment on open litigation, WOU personnel or student matters. We appreciate your understanding and patience as the university handles this matter and will share updates as appropriate.”
Kafoury alleged that Western negligently hired Peatross despite her controversial history at previous institutions. The lawsuit claims the university failed to properly vet her background and overlooked allegations of abusive behavior at Salem University, her prior coaching job in West Virginia. Additionally, line 208 of the complaint document alleges that both Peatross and Marlow “lied on their resumes and lacked requisite qualifications,” raising further questions about the university’s hiring practices.
Kafoury went on to state, “Western Oregon University hired an abusive coach, and when the student-athletes stood up to the horrible treatment, they were retaliated against by losing their basketball careers and scholarships.” He argued that this lawsuit is not just about Western, but about setting a precedent that holds coaches responsible for their treatment of student-athletes. The claim suggests that if universities continue to overlook red flags in hiring while also failing to address player concerns, they could face similar legal and financial repercussions.
“This case is about sending a message to coaches across the country that they just can’t treat players this way and get away with it,” said Kafoury.
Western has yet to release a detailed response to the student body and local community regarding the dispute.
The lawsuit has sparked mixed reactions among students here at Western. One student commented, “I am extremely nervous for the future of Western. If this goes through — it could be detrimental for us.” A first-year student stated, “I was not fully aware of what was even going on, but now I am a little concerned considering I am a freshman planning to graduate from Western.” However, skepticism remains among some students, with one saying, “I wonder if anything really happened, or if this story is fabricated due to a losing season. I guess time will tell.”
This lawsuit brings potentially broader issues to light regarding the importance of player welfare and university accountability. If successful, it could set an example for how institutions should handle abuse allegations within collegiate athletics. As the legal battle unfolds, Western faces not only financial consequences but also a reputational crisis that could impact recruitment, enrollment and the future of its athletics program. The outcome of this case may serve as a landmark decision in the evolving conversation about player rights and coaching accountability in college sports.
Contact the author at howlsports@wou.edu
